Best Buy It for Life Walking shoes

Explore the best walking shoes, based on 58 Reddit mentions and the conversations behind them.

Updated on

New Balance

The New Balance 990v6 is a Made in USA walking/running sneaker, and owners here recommend the 990 line mainly for comfort and fit: wide sizes suit flat feet and heavier users. Many buy 990s again and again, replacing old pairs with the same model. That said, owners are honest that it isn't truly buy-it-for-life: some note the 990 tests as less durable than the 574, and daily-wear sneakers usually last about a heavy-mileage year. If you want a comfortable, well-built shoe you'll rebuy rather than keep forever, it fits.

How long it lasts

owners replace them about yearly under heavy daily wear 6

What owners like

  • Very comfortable and people rebuy the same model repeatedly 12
  • Wide sizes work well for flat feet and heavier users 23
  • Well-built and a popular pick across the 990/99x line 24

Common complaints

  • Not truly BIFL; may be less durable than the New Balance 574 15
Buy now

Lone Peak

$145.00

Altra

The Altra Lone Peak 9 is a zero-drop trail shoe with a wide toe box, sold for around $140-145. Owners pick it because the roomy forefoot lets toes spread, it needs no break-in, and it stays comfortable on hikes, country walks, and long days of travel. Several say their foot issues eased after switching. It suits walkers and hikers who value comfort over outright durability; as one owner notes, trail-shoe foams and rubbers degrade, so these are not true buy-it-for-life footwear.

How long it lasts

one owner has worn the brand daily for 8 years 7

What owners like

  • Wide toe box lets toes spread and eased foot issues 123
  • No break-in period and comfortable from day one 14
  • No shin splints or plantar fasciitis issues 4
  • Light and grippy, good for travel and everyday walking 51

Common complaints

  • Not much cushion, so those needing more support may prefer another shoe 1
  • Not true BIFL: trail runner foams and rubbers degrade fairly quickly 6
Buy now

Adidas

The Adidas Ultraboost 1.0 is a cushioned running/walking shoe with a foam midsole and Continental rubber tread, priced around $119-$180 (owners report finding it discounted). Owners praise its comfort for long days on their feet, wide-foot and heavy users say the heel support works well, and many call it durable, with one estimating thousands of miles versus a few hundred for typical walking shoes. One owner's pair lasted 2 years of daily wear; another's family pair is 6 years old. The main caveat is the toe box is not roomy, so fit can vary.

How long it lasts

owners report 2 years of daily wear, and a 6-year-old pair still in use 26

What owners like

  • Comfortable for long shifts on your feet 12
  • Good heel support and workable for wide, heavy users 3
  • Durable sole with Continental rubber tread 4
  • Sweet spot of comfort and style 5

Common complaints

  • Pricey at full retail 2
  • Toe box not roomy 3
Buy now

Brooks

The Brooks Ghost Max 2 is a $160 cushioned walking/running shoe. Owners walking long daily distances say it's the most comfortable shoe they've owned, with a forward-rolling feel. Others have stayed with the Brooks Ghost line for a decade, calling it like walking on a cloud. It suits heavy walkers and people on their feet for hours. Honest caveat: most of the feedback here is about the Ghost line generally, and one user points out running shoes are meant to be replaced regularly, so this isn't a buy-it-for-life item.

What owners like

  • most comfortable shoe ever owned, feels like it propels you forward during 2-hour daily walks 1
  • has worn Brooks Ghost exclusively for 10 years after trying them at a running store 2

Common complaints

  • running shoes wear out and are meant to be replaced, so longevity is limited by design 3
Buy now

New Balance

The New Balance 990v6 is a Made in USA athletic sneaker that owners treat as a core everyday shoe. One user keeps three pairs in different colors and wears them as the main athletic option, and others use them for all-day walking, including trips abroad where they swapped to dressier shoes only for dinner. Comfort is praised, though one owner ranks the New Balance 1080 above it. The honest caveat: these comments are short endorsements rather than long-term wear reports, so there's no stated evidence yet on how many years a pair holds up.

What owners like

  • Likes it enough to own three pairs in different colors 1
  • Used as main everyday and travel walking shoe 23
  • Very enthusiastic endorsement 4
  • Comfortable, though 1080s rated higher 5
Buy now

Brooks

The Brooks Adrenaline GTS 22 is a stability running shoe that owners also wear for everyday walking. People with plantar fasciitis, flat feet, and sore knees say its support helped their pain fade, and one owner notes the shoes last a long time if you avoid gravel. It suits people who need solid support rather than a plush, floaty feel. The honest caveat: one user points out running shoes are meant to be replaced after a while, so they aren't a true buy-it-for-life pick, and getting properly fitted at a running store is advised.

How long it lasts

Owners say this shoe lasts a long time, especially without heavy gravel running 3

What owners like

  • Support helped ease plantar fasciitis pain 1
  • Good stability support for flat feet 2
  • Helped resolve sore knee pain 3

Common complaints

  • Running shoes are meant to be replaced eventually, so not truly long-lasting 4
  • Some prefer more stabilizing models like the Brooks Beast 5
Buy now

Brooks

The Brooks Addiction Walker 2 is a supportive walking shoe that owners say lasts for years. It comes in several widths, including 2E and 4E options, in both men's and women's sizing, and owners recommend getting fitted since some sizes run narrow. The all-black leather version is popular because it looks professional enough for work. Replacement insoles are available, extending the shoe's usable life. It suits people who need sturdy support for walking or who want a work-friendly black shoe. One caveat: prices mentioned by owners put the shoes around $130 and replacement insoles around $60.

How long it lasts

Owners say the shoes hold up and last for years 1

What owners like

  • Supportive shoe that holds up for years 12
  • Available in multiple widths for men and women 12
  • Black leather version passes for business casual wear 34
  • Replacement insoles can extend the shoe's life 1

Common complaints

  • Some 2E widths run narrow; getting fitted is advised 1
  • Shoes and replacement insoles add up in cost 1
Buy now

928v3

$159.95

New Balance

The New Balance 928v3 is a $160 men's walking shoe, and owners say it holds up unusually well. One 285-lb owner who walks for hours daily reports a pair lasting 12 years with the original soles and leather still intact, helped by swapping in fresh insoles every couple of years and rotating between shoes. Owners call it the most comfortable walking shoe made, and note it's one of the few ordinary shoes Medicare approves for diabetics. The repeated caveat: it's ugly. It suits heavy walkers who prioritize support over looks.

How long it lasts

One owner reports 12 years of frequent walking with soles and leather still in good shape 1

What owners like

  • Extreme durability even under heavy use 1
  • Most comfortable walking shoe, Medicare-approved for diabetics 2
  • Considered the best walking shoe available 3

Common complaints

  • Widely called ugly 234
Buy now

New Balance

The designers of the first 990 were tasked with creating the single best running shoe on the market. The MADE in USA 990v6 embraces this original mandate, with a series of performance-inspired updates. The upper dispenses with the standard midfoot saddle, allowing the suede and synthetic overlays to flow from heel to toe across the mesh underlay, for a speedy, streamlined look. While the evolved design marks one of the most dramatic changes from one generation model to the next that the 990 has ever seen, the greatest leap forward occurs on the inside. The addition of FuelCell midsole cushioning means that the evolution of the 990 can be felt as much as it can be seen. As part of the MADE in…

Reddit mentions

  • “New Balance 990 V4. Made in America.”
  • “On our last trip to Germany, my fiancee and I had two pairs each: a matching set of New Balance 990v6 and a “dressier” white/brown shoe (like an OnCloud Roger or Cole Haan…”
  • “This is going to be really strange sounding but I bought a new pair of 990v6s for my Japan trip and the bottoms got eaten up probably because of the yellow tactile pavement on the…”
Buy now