Based on 4 r/BuyItForLife mentions

Classic Toaster

$59.99

Cuisinart

The Cuisinart 4 – Slot Toaster is the perfect appliance for every kitchen. Toaster features four 1.5” toasting slots and a slide-out crumb tray for convenient and quick clean up. Dual 6-setting dials are designed so that each side of toaster can be set to different browning shades for a custom toasting experience. Defrost, Reheat and Bagel buttons feature light up LED indicators and can be used for toasting any type of bread. Use the extra-lift carriage lever to remove toast easily without getting burned. A convenient cord wrap is included to protect the cord and make storage easier. The sleek design of the black brushed stainless steel and polished chrome accents make this appliance the per…

Reddit mentions

  • “I ended up choosing the Cuisinart CPT-180, which reliably toasts both sides evenly and fits well under the $150 mark.”
  • “I've had the best luck with the Cuisinart CPT-180. It actually toasts both sides evenly, which shouldn’t be a big ask, but apparently, it is. It’s sturdy, has a classic design, and…”
  • “Cuisinart two-slice toaster. I want to replace it but the thing just won’t die – and we’re talking 20-years now”
Buy now
Product details
Number of Slices
4
Slot Type
Wide
Color
Polished chrome, Black, Brushed stainless steel
Highlighted Features
Dual control panels, Defrost function, Slide-out crumb tray
Included Items
Toaster
Toasting Evenness
Uneven cooking resulted in patchy colors and a pale center (heating frozen strudel)
Automatic Shut-off
Yes
Cool Touch Exterior
Yes
Wattage
1800 W
Voltage
120 Volts
Size
4 Slice
Depth
10.65"
Height
7.5"
Width
11.15"
Weight
6.400 lbs
Browning Levels
6
Preset Programs
Bagel, Defrost, Reheat
Controls Type
Custom controls, Dual control panels
Number of Settings
6
Indicator Lights
LED indicators
Crumb Tray
Yes
Dishwasher Safe Parts
No
Housing Material
Metal, Stainless Steel
Internal Material
Non-stick interior
Finish
Polished chrome
Style
Classic
Cord Storage
Yes (convenient cord wrap)
Included Accessories
Instruction book
Compatible Accessories
Warming rack
Cord Length
2 ft
Smart Features
No (works with the google assistant), No (app compatibility), No (bluetooth compatibility)
Energy Efficiency
No (energy star qualified)
Top Use Cases
Toasting bread, Toasting bagels, Toasting pastries
Typical Users
You and a friend